What were the Disciples Really Asking?
    Provocative Articles Category
    Open In A New Window
    Add Your Comment At The Bottom
    Add Notes about this Page

    What were the disciples really asking:

    "When will be the sign of your coming?"

    Let the Bible interpret itself!!!

    Question:

    Matthew 24:3

    Mark 13:3-4

    Luke 21:7

    Question #1

    When will these things be?When will these things be? When will these things be?

    Question #2

    What is sign of your coming & the end of the age? Sign when all these things

    will be fulfilled?

    Sign when these things are

    about to take place?

    A. Concepts The Disciples Didn't Understand:

    1. They didn't understand his death: Mt 16:21-22; Lk 18:31-34; Jn 16:16-18; 20:9
    2. They didn't understand the second coming: Jn 13:36-14:6;
    3. They thought kingdom was physical: Jn 18:36 Lk 17:20-21 Vs. Lk 19:11; Acts 1:6

    B. What Was In Their Mind When They Said, "End Of The Age"?

    1. End of Jewish age or climax of the temple destruction not second coming?
      • "end of the world" is incorrect; should be literally, "consummation of the ages"
      • Vine:"doesn't denote a termination, but heading up of events to the appointed climax"
      • In Mt 24:14 the end is used in reference to 70AD not second coming
      • Christ's first advent: "at the consummation of the ages" He was manifested", Heb 9:26
      • There may have been no connection with the second coming at all in their mind.
    2. Second coming, destruction of the planet?
      • Was end of the ages terminology which they used in Mt 24 learned from Jesus teaching in the parables tares & fishnet: Mt 13:39,40,49-51? Notice esp V51
      • They definitely equated the phrase "end of the age" with the temple destruction
      • If expression came from tares, then they incorrectly applied it to the temple
      • I believe they misapplied the tares teaching to the temple but Jesus then corrects them
      • Jesus' answer in Mt 24:1-25:30 vs. 25:31-46 shows he dealt with the two subjects.

image